Any and all correction to the following minutes will be made at the
09/18/03 Newfane Selectboard’s meeting and are considered unapproved
until then. Corrections will be noted in the minutes of that meeting.
MINUTES - REGULAR MEETING - BOARD OF SELECTMEN
SEPTEMBER 4th, 2003
NEWFANE TOWN OFFICE
PRESENT:
Selectmen: Piet van Loon, Gorty Baldwin, Priscilla Cotton, Gary Katz and
Chris Williams.
Also Present: Andy McPhail, James Borta, Edward Druke, Sr., David Clarkson,
James O. Gray as Road Foreman and Doris Knechtel as Administrative Assistant.
1. CALL
TO ORDER
The regular meeting was called to order by Chairman Piet van Loon at 6:32
p.m.
2. SCHEDULED MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC
A. ANDY McPHAIL - PAINTING WILLIAMSVILLE HALL
Andy McPhail was invited by the Board to review some of the issues for
the painting of the Williamsville Hall. A. McPhail indicated that he has
worked for sometime with Toby Mo as a subcontractor. He has found out
that there is lead paint. It was reported that the building was painted
in the ‘70's by Jonathan Julian. A manual from the Department of
Health, obtained by P. van Loon was given to A. McPhail regarding proper
procedures to be followed where lead paint is involved. A. McPhail will
review the manual and take the precautions necessary for dealing with
the lead paint. If there is any problem he is to get back to the Board.
B. OPENING OF BIDS - HEATING FUEL
The following bids were received for the purchase of #2 heating fuel for
the town buildings and for the NewBrook and South Newfane/Williamsville
Fire Departments.
| Barrows/Fisher |
Pre-paid
- 10,000 gallons at $1.019 per gallon |
$10,190 |
| Cota
& Cota |
Fixed
Pricing - WSJ - Nymex futures NY Barge
(WSJ -Wall Street Journal) Tractor Trailer delivery Spot Pricing -
WSJ - NY Barge cash price DOD
Tractor Trailer delivery |
$0.55
over close
$0.37
over close
$0.55 over close
$0.37 over close |
| Sandri,
Inc. |
Pre-paid
- 10,000 gallons at $1.048 per gallon -
Payment due no later than September 20th |
$10,480 |
Cota &
Cota will be contacted about the Wall Street Journal pricing means. The
fire departments will be contacted to let them know what the bids prices
per gallon are.
3. UNSCHEDULED MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC
A. Jim Borta of the Newfane Store was present to talk with the Board regarding
his concerns about the traffic on VT Route 30. A copy of the letter from
the state was given to him which indicates that the speed limit is to
be lowered to 30 mph. J. Borta indicated that he would like to see three
to four crosswalks painted in at the Town Office/Post Office area, Jail
Street/West Street, Jail Street/Court Street and Cemetery Hill Road to
the Bank. He has heard about traffic calming measures, such as islands
and does not see anything happening. He also suggested a solar powered
flashing light and signs for pedestrian crossings.
P van Loon indicated that there is quite a background on the matter of
traffic calming as it Minutes - Newfane Board of Selectmen’s Regular
Meeting - 09/04/03 Page #2
3. UNSCHEDULED MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC - (cont.)
relates to the Village of Newfane. It was suggested that the Village Trustees
be invited to the next meeting to discuss the various proposals made and
to develop a single letter to the state on the matter.
B. E. Druke has some concerns regarding Newfane Hill Road (TH#20) &
Upper Spring Hill Road (TH#23) that can wait until J. Gray arrives at
the meeting.
C. D. Clarkson spoke of the report received and recommendations made by
the Traffic Calming Committee. One of the major suggestions was for increased
speed enforcement by the Vermont State Police and the Windham County Sheriff’s
Department. One of the members of the committee feels that there should
be 24/7 coverage. That scenario would be cost prohibitive at this time
with current budgets. The VSP and the WCSD will be invited to a Selectboard
meeting in the near future. Comparative costs and revenue for law enforcement
will be reviewed.
D. D. Clarkson also discussed the recent traffic count that was done on
South Wardsboro Road (TH#1) by Windham Regional Commission. P. van Loon
gave the Board members a copy of the summary results of the survey. The
speed limit range near the Clarkson/Kafka site was 36 to 41 mph going
in an easterly direction and 31 to 38 mph in a westerly direction. At
the Eddy Road site, the speed limit range was 31 - 35 mph in each direction.
Currently the speed limit on TH#1 is 30 mph to 35 mph depending on the
location. Some felt that changing the speed limit is not the answer, enforcement
is.
4. ROAD BUSINESS
4. A. ROAD COMMISSIONER’S REPORT - (See attached
report)
(1) Item #6.D. - It has been suggested that TH#31 (Penner Road) be discontinued.
A list of other roads will be considered for discontinuance.
(2) Item #5 - Motion was made by G. Katz and seconded by P. Cotton to
approve the Verizon Petition and Order (#9AAHE1)for Pole and Wire Locations
off Dover Road (TH#2) onto Penner Road (TH#31). Unanimous.
4. B. ROAD FOREMAN’S REPORT - (See attached report)
(1) Item #2 - Paving has begun on Dover Road (TH#2) and should be completed
by Friday weather permitting. The side dressing will occur at a later
date.
4. D. ACCESS/RIGHT OF WAY PERMITS
No Access/Right of Way Permits were presented to the Board for action.
4. F. OTHER ROAD BUSINESS
(1) Bridge #49, the South Newfane Green Iron Bridge is to be paved up
to the drain.
(2) The pre-construction meeting was held here at the Town Office on September
3rd for the Brookline/Newfane bridge (BR#19) with representatives from
the state, Brookline and Newfane Selectmen and the contractor, Renaud
Bros., Inc. The temporary bridge is to be in by November. There will be
some work on the bridge during the winter months.
(3) The surveyor for the South Wardsboro Road (TH#1) project will be contacting
to set up a meeting with G. Katz and J. Gray to review the project.
(4) C. Williams suggested that the Board should be putting funds away
to replace a narrow 9' bridge (BR#37) with no railings with a wider bridge
on upper Adams Hill Road (TH#27).
(5) It was suggested that J. Gray be asked about coming to the meeting
earlier, 7:30 p.m. so that road matters are discussed at one time, without
having to repeat information. The other alternative would be to wait until
8:00 p.m. before any road business is discussed.
5. OLD BUSINESS
A. PERSONNEL POLICY
Copies of the proposed Personnel Policy are to be given to the three new
Board members for their review and comments. The Board will meet with
the employees affected by the policy.
B. TRAFFIC ORDINANCE REVIEW - No discussion
C. DOG ORDINANCE REVIEW
The Board members discussed reviewing current Dog Ordinance with the thought
of amending it to mirror the Vermont Statutes more closely. Other ideas
discussed included changing the name to Animal Control Ordinance, looking
at what other towns do and including wolf-hybrids. It was noted that wolf-hybrids
is already mentioned in the current ordinance. The Town Constable, Kevin
Behan will be included in any proposed amendment discussions.
D. ACCESS/RIGHT OF WAY POLICY DISCUSSION
The Board discussed various aspects of having a stand alone document or
if it should be incorporated with the Traffic Ordinance. The town has
an application without any policy or ordinance to back it up. There is
not a fee for the permit nor is there any penalty for those who construct
an access or place something with the town highway right of way without
a permit. Those who install a temporary logging access are usually the
ones do not obtain a permit. Education is the key to letting residents
know what permits are needed. By and large the current access procedure
is working okay except for those few who do not get a permit, and there
is currently no mechanism for a penalty. P. van Loon will look over the
sample ordinance from Grafton and present something to the Board.
E. OTHER OLD BUSINESS
(1) Phoenix Roofing needs to be contacted to remind them that they were
to look at both the Town Office and Williamsville Hall for slate repairs.
6. NEW BUSINESS
A. APPOINTMENTS
(1) REPRESENTATIVE TO RESCUE, INC.
Merle Tessier is not interested at this time in serving as the Newfane
Rescue, Inc. representative. The town will need to get the word out through
the minutes, the website and the Butterfly publication.
B. SCHEDULE MEETINGS WITH BOARDS, TOWNS AND AGENCIES
The Village Trustees will be invited to a meeting to discuss VT Route
30 Traffic Calming and other matters on September 16th. The WCSD and the
VSP are to be invited to discuss Law Enforcement. The Board will contact
representatives of the Leland & Gray Board and the Elementary School
Board to discuss unfunded mandates and other concerns of the school and
town for Thursday, October 16th.
C. DOG HEARING REPORT
Board members reviewed the report of the findings and decision of the
dog hearing. The minutes of the hearing, Exhibit #9, have not yet been
completed. Motion was made by G. Katz and seconded by G. Baldwin to approve
the Vicious Dog Hearing findings and decision as prepared. Unanimous.
There will be a section added for signatures. The Board agreed to have
a special meeting on Tuesday, September 9th beginning at 6:30 p.m. to
consider the minutes of the dog hearing.
7. ADMINISTRATIVE
ASSISTANT’S REPORT - (See attached report)
A. Item #4 - Motion was made by G. Baldwin and seconded by G. Katz to
grant permission to close Church Street (TH#55) and a portion of West
Street (TH#1) on Saturday, October 11th and Sunday, October 12th between
the hours of 9:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m. Unanimous.
B. Item #3 - The problem with the Garland range is that one of the ovens
“went out” after operating for a while. Those running the
Senior Meal at the time took quick action to use the ovens at the South
Newfane/Williamsville Fire Station.
8. MINUTES
The Board reviewed the minutes of the Regular Meeting of 08/21/03. Motion
was made by G. Katz and seconded by C. Williams to approve the minutes
of the Regular Meeting of 08/21/03, as written. Unanimous. Minutes of
07/01/03 and 07/17/03 are incomplete at this time. There was some discussion
about trying to reduce the content of the minutes to be able to get them
done on a more timely manner.
9. PAY ORDERS
Motion was made by P. Cotton and seconded by C. Williams to approve the
Newfane Payroll and Accounts Payable Warrants for the following amounts:
08/23/03 Payroll $ 2,949.27
08/30/03 Payroll $ 2,835.00
09/01/03 Payroll $ 2,629.51
09/05/03 Acct.’s Payable #6 $ 341,286.70 Unanimous.
IRS Electronic Federal Payroll Tax Payments
08/27/03 $ 1,126.82
09/03/03 $ 889.19
10. CORRESPONDENCE
A. The Selectboard received a letter of thanks from Bruce Hesselbach,
Chairman of the Newfane Conservation Commission regarding the handling
of the payment in advance for the grant monies for work done on the town
trails. The state has since reimbursed the town.
B. The Selectboard has received an extensive letter from Bruce Hesselbach
, Chairman of the Newfane Conservation Commission, regarding the location
of the parking area at the town garage site for the hiking trails. The
temporary variance for the existing parking expires in October of 2003.
The letter explains the reasons that the CC favors keeping the parking
area where it is currently located as it serves the purpose. The area
is behind a stone wall with angle parking for about 5 vehicles with an
entrance and an exit. The area does not meet the Zoning setback requirements.
It was agreed that a new application and request for a variance for the
existing parking should be filed with the ZA and the ZBA.
C. The letter from Lucy Hudock involving a road matter will be reviewed
by the Road Commissioner and the Road Foreman.
D. Notification has been received that there will be an Act 250 hearing
for Eagle River Mining on Wednesday, October 8, 2003 with a site visit
at 8:30 a.m. with the hearing to follow at the Newfane Town Office.
E. A copy of the Pre-Filed Testimony for West River Acres, Inc. As filed
with the VT State Environmental Board has been received from Attorney
Timothy O’Connor.
11. EXECUTIVE SESSION
Motion was made by P. Cotton and seconded by G. Katz to enter into Executive
Session at 9:23 p.m. to discuss a matter of pending litigation. Unanimous.
Motion was made by G. Baldwin and seconded by P. Cotton to come out of
Executive Session at 9:31 p.m. Unanimous. No action was recommended to
be taken during the session.
4. F. OTHER ROAD BUSINESS - (cont.)
(6) G. Katz indicated that he spoke with some of the members of the highway
crew regarding a morale issue. The Board members discussed the matter.
The Board indicated that they feel that the highway crew is doing a good
job and if the employees would like, the Board will sit down to discuss
the crews concerns either separately or together at a Special Meeting.
It was also suggested that the crew be sent to some of the workshops that
occur from time to time for road issues. As per the current Personnel
Policy, workshop is paid for by the town, mileage to the workshop is reimbursable
and the employee is paid for the day at the regular rate.
12. ADJOURNMENT
Motion was made by G. Katz and seconded by P. Cotton to adjourn the Regular
Meeting of the Board at 10:26 p.m. Unanimous.
Doris A.
Knechtel
Administrative Assistant
Newfane Board of Selectmen
Posted: Town
Clerk's Office, Newfane Store, Williamsville General Store, and South
Newfane General Store & Deli.
www.newfanevt.com
ROAD
COMMISSIONER’S REPORT of 09/04/03
1. Stratton
Hill Road Telephone Poles
Verizon still needs permission from one of the property owners to move
the location of a pole. They are anxious, but it would be inappropriate
for the Board to act before permission is received from the property owner.
Once permission is received, this will be an approvable permit application.
2. Bridge Work and Paving
The bridge on Bruce Brook Road (BR#32) is almost complete. Also, the pre-construction
conference was held about the Brookline Bridge (BR#19). Looks like things
are moving along. The paving contractor has begun the work on Dover Road
(TH#2) and Monroe Bridge (BR#15).
3. Red Chaffee Request
Red Chaffee called to express concern that his road had washed in the
recent rains and that other problems he has pointed out have not been
corrected. He would like the Board to schedule a site visit on his road
as we did on Newfane Hill Road (TH#20). (Jim says the road has been worked
on this summer, but that there are still areas that need attention.)
4. Lucy Hudock Letter
Jim and I will visit the site next week.
5. Penner Road Telephone Pole
The proposed new location for this pole looks fine and is an improvement
over the current location. Board can approve the request.
6. Other Items
A. I met with the road crew to talk about their concerns about what they
see as inappropriate criticism and complaints as well as abusive behavior
toward them. Crew morale is an issue we need to discuss.
B. The scheduled replacement of the Loader looks like it will be needed.
C. Jim and the crew indicate a need for new radios in the equipment to
improve communications.
D. Jim suggests that Penner Road from the fork on up the hill is actually
a private driveway and is one of the roads the Town should consider giving
up.
Gary Katz,
Road Commissioner
ROAD
FOREMAN’S REPORT 09/04/03
TOWN OF NEWFANE HIGHWAY
1. Upper
Spring Hill Road (TH#23) was shaped up after ditch was washed out. Wiswall
Hill Road (TH#11) from Eager Road (TH#13) to Teddy Carey’s, Beetlestone
Hill Road (TH#47), Beetlestone Drive (TH#25), Wheeler Hill Road (TH#26)
and Baker Brook Road (TH#19) were graded and raked.
2. Lane Construction
has started paving Dover Road (TH#2). Weather permitting, paving will
be done Friday.
3. Bridge
#32 (Bruce Brook Road - TH#21) is nearing completion.
4. Verizon
Job #9AAHE1 on Penner Road should be approved. Verizon Job#9AAGZ0 Stratton
Hill Road needs approval for Pole#P45 and anchor from owner.
5. Equipment:
A. All other equipment is operational.
Respectfully
submitted,
James O. Gray, Road Foreman |